Burnhearts

Burnhearts is a standout bar nestled in the heart of Milwaukee’s vibrant Bay View neighborhood at 2599 S Logan Ave. From the moment you step inside, you're welcomed into an intimate, warm atmosphere that perfectly balances a classic Irish pub vibe with an eclectic, hometown charm. Whether you’re retreating indoors to soak in its dim, cozy ambiance or enjoying the relaxed outdoor seating on a crisp evening, Burnhearts crafts an inviting space where locals and visitors alike can savor remarkable drinks and unwind in style.

The beverage selection here is nothing short of impressive and tailored for true beer lovers and cocktail aficionados. From the rich depth of the Central Waters Bourbon Barrel Barleywine to the crisp effervescence of lager favorites like Lager of the Lakes and Grain Belt beer, Burnhearts offers a curated lineup that will satisfy both casual sippers and seasoned connoisseurs. Their taps showcase a rotating variety, including standout brews like Dogfish Head | 60 Min IPA, Bruery Beret Raspberry Sour, and the distinctive Bourbon Barrel Stout from Against The Grain. If cider, kombucha, or hard seltzer is more your style, options such as Juneshine Midnight Painkiller, Vander Mill Ginger Zere Hard Cider, and White Claw are also thoughtfully available.

For those craving something comforting to pair with their drinks, Burnhearts serves up delicious Pulled Pork and Pulled Mushroom Sandwiches—hearty and flavorful bites that perfectly complement the drink experience without overpowering it. The careful balance of smoky, tender fillings on fresh bread creates a satisfying harmony with the complex layers in their cocktail and beer offerings.

Customer experiences at Burnhearts truly bring the spirit of the place to life. Jerry Locke celebrates the venue for its excellent selection and outstanding service during special occasions like the Central Waters 20th anniversary event, emphasizing the welcoming nature of the staff and the memorable atmosphere. Amy Shenk captures the essence of the bar’s charm, highlighting the creative, tiki-inspired cocktails like the “Dreamsicle” and “I’m Not a Taurus,” which are as balanced in flavor as they are intriguing in concept. Regulars like Katy Klinnert and Jeffrey Hotson describe Burnhearts as a beloved neighborhood escape—a place they return to time and again for quiet drinks, excellent value, and that special Irish-pub ambiance that never feels overdone.

Whether you are browsing through Milwaukee’s bar scene or seeking a cozy spot to raise a glass with friends, Burnhearts feels like a hidden gem crafted with care. It’s a place where every sip carries with it a sense of history and community, and every visit feels like coming home. From expertly poured Irish Coffee to thoughtfully brewed IPAs, this bar invites you to slow down, savor your drink, and soak up an atmosphere you won’t soon forget.

Next time you’re in Bay View, make sure Burnhearts is on your list—it’s more than just a bar; it’s a Milwaukee experience etched into every warm pour and smiling server.